Upon further review, instant replay needs a tune-up

col-tbuzz (2)Upon further review … The NFL’s instant-replay rule needs further review.

Before you roll your eyes and click on something else, this is not one of those reactionary cries that come every time a controversial call costs a team a ballgame, or a pitcher or no-hitter, or my fantasy man Buddha (“fantasy” as in league, not as in dreams) some points in one of his 87 leagues.

This is call that instant replay is suffering from overexposure. What began as a well-intentioned method of correcting blown calls that were the difference between winning and losing has exploded into nit-picking intrusion that causes unnecessary delays in the action to make minor fixes to rulings.

I am on the record as being pro-instant replay, and I still am. But the NFL has to find a way to limit the use cutting-edge technology from interrupting the flow of its games. The rampant use of replay and the development of high-definition video is quickly turning NFL games into an episode of CSI.

TD or No TD is a valid question, but do we really need TV to tell us if Player O’s toenail stepped out of bounds before Player X targeted him with the crown of his helmet? Or if the football broke some imaginary plane before the knee of the person holding it touched the ground? It’s like a Zapruder film marathon.

The footage that broke the camels back came during Sunday night’s showcase between the Kansas City Chiefs and Denver Broncos. After watching some of the most time-wasting replays all Sunday, the NFL saved its most ridiculous reviews for last, turning the last 5 minutes into an eternity and stretching the forgone conclusion of a game well past midnight.

The first one was fairly understandable: Trailing 27-10, Chiefs tight end Anthony Fasano made a leaping catch in the back of the end zone that was ruled out of bounds. But, upon further review and about 5 earth minutes, the head referee emerged from the hood to explain that Fasano’s right calf muscle touched in bounds before his butt cheek hit out of bounds. Body parts? Really?

After the call was overturned and the Broncos attempted to mercifully run out the clock, Wes Welker caught a pass and, while running out of bounds, stuck the football forward toward the first-down mark. Fourth down, said the ref. Challenge the spot, said the Broncos. So after surgerically breaking down the exact location of the ball at the exact moment he stepped out of bounds, the ball was respotted at the 31 1/4-yard line. That’s the 31 yard, 9-inch line for those without X-ray vision.

College football has an even bigger problem with its new targeting rule. If a referee thinks he says the call, he throws the flag, the offending player is ejected and the play is automatically reviewed. If the replay shows the player, in fact, did not illegal target, he gets to stay in the game but the penalty remains.  Try that in the real world: A judge tears up your ticket because he finds you not guilty but you still have to pay the fine.

The NFL and NCAA keep no stats on replay usage but the offseason rule change to review every scoring play, coupled with teams using assistants in the press box to green light or red light a review, is turning a nation of football fans into forensic scientists. And when the scene of the crime is prime time, casual viewers start flipping to the Puppy Bowl.

Comments

comments

Seahawks trio, Socastee's Solomon in all-star games

Seahawks trio, Socastee's Solomon in all-star gamesThree Myrtle Beach Seahawks and one Socastee Brave will represent [more]

Local runners place fourth at MB Mini-Marathon, 5K

Local runners place fourth at MB Mini-Marathon, 5KBrian Polen of Wooster, OH won the Myrtle Beach Mini-Marathon [more]

CAC dominates as host of Coastal Classic Invitational

CAC dominates as host of Coastal Classic InvitationalCoastal Aquatic Club (CAC) hosted its 10th annual Coastal Classic [more]

Chants use strong second half to upend Minutemen

Chants use strong second half to upend MinutemenCoastal Carolina football shook off four missed scoring opportunities in [more]

Region 6-4A: Doty's 7 TDs lift MB; Foxes rock Chiefs

Region 6-4A: Doty's 7 TDs lift MB; Foxes rock ChiefsWhat was expected to be No. 4-ranked Myrtle Beach's toughest [more]

Panthers suffer first defeat in showdown with Knights

Panthers suffer first defeat in showdown with KnightsThe Carolina Forest offense watched nearly helplessly as Ailym Ford [more]

Region 6-5A: Tigers topple Sharks; Bruins blast Braves

Region 6-5A: Tigers topple Sharks; Bruins blast BravesConway continued its impressive midseason turnaround by capturing a 37-14 [more]

Chiefs top Seahawks, cap clean sweep to region title

Chiefs top Seahawks, cap clean sweep to region titleThe North Myrtle Beach High volleyball team completed a rare [more]

Despite turnover, Panthers continue region dominance

Despite turnover, Panthers continue region dominanceAvery Campbell didn’t expect to celebrate a region championship this [more]

CF's Hatfield, boys team claim Region 6-5A titles

CF's Hatfield, boys team claim Region 6-5A titlesAll five Carolina Forest boys runners placed in the top [more]

Coastal opens long road trip with win at Clemson

Coastal opens long road trip with win at ClemsonFor the second time in less than a year, Coastal [more]

Wilson takes keys, drives Seahawks to 100th victory

Wilson takes keys, drives Seahawks to 100th victoryMickey Wilson vaguely remembers Scott Earley approaching him in April [more]

Only MB stands between NMB sweep to region title

Only MB stands between NMB sweep to region titleThe North Myrtle Beach High volleyball team has run the [more]

Week 9 Previews & Picks: Big night of football on tap

Week 9 Previews & Picks: Big night of football on tapWeek 9 is the kickoff of crunch time on the [more]

Legette's comeback puts CF foes in a real 'Catch 22'

Legette's comeback puts CF foes in a real 'Catch 22'David Legette knows his coaches could have moved on for [more]

NMB girls win region title; MB boys finish runner-up

NMB girls win region title; MB boys finish runner-upThe North Myrtle Beach High girls cross country team won [more]

Golf: CF, SJ qualify in 5A; MB, NMB finish 2-3 in 4A

Golf: CF, SJ qualify in 5A; MB, NMB finish 2-3 in 4AThe St. James girls golf team was runner-up at Monday's [more]

CF's Runyon makes home run to coach alma mater

CF's Runyon makes home run to coach alma materFormer Carolina Forest High and University of Alabama softball standout [more]

Tennis: Seahawks start long week with win over Wilson

Tennis: Seahawks start long week with win over WilsonThe Myrtle Beach girls tennis team breezed through another region [more]

CCU baseball at Clemson, hosts UNCW in fall season

CCU baseball at Clemson, hosts UNCW in fall seasonWith fall practice in full swing, Coastal Carolina baseball head [more]

Volleyball: Chiefs, Panthers take broom to region rivals

Volleyball: Chiefs, Panthers take broom to region rivalsThe North Myrtle Beach volleyball team continued its unbeaten run [more]

Coast FA boys teams earn Charleston Shootout titles

Coast FA boys teams earn Charleston Shootout titlesThree Coast FA boys select teams returned home with hardware [more]

Chants suffer Sun Belt loss to Warhawks on home turf

Chants suffer Sun Belt loss to Warhawks on home turfCoastal Carolina fell behind early and played from behind for [more]

Week 8 Roundup: Wilson wins 100th; Tigers prevail

Week 8 Roundup: Wilson wins 100th; Tigers prevailMyrtle Beach football coach Mickey Wilson's teams are known for [more]

Panthers stroll past Sharks, set up key 6-5A showdown

Panthers stroll past Sharks, set up key 6-5A showdownCarolina Forest is typically pretty reserved when it comes to [more]

Seahawks trio, Socastee's Solomon in all-star games

Seahawks trio, Socastee's Solomon in all-star gamesThree Myrtle Beach Seahawks and one Socastee Brave will represent [more]

Local runners place fourth at MB Mini-Marathon, 5K

Local runners place fourth at MB Mini-Marathon, 5KBrian Polen of Wooster, OH won the Myrtle Beach Mini-Marathon [more]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2018 Grand Strand Sports Report · RSS
Myrtle Beach Web Design
Kayaking in Myrtle Beach