Upon further review, instant replay needs a tune-up

col-tbuzz (2)Upon further review … The NFL’s instant-replay rule needs further review.

Before you roll your eyes and click on something else, this is not one of those reactionary cries that come every time a controversial call costs a team a ballgame, or a pitcher or no-hitter, or my fantasy man Buddha (“fantasy” as in league, not as in dreams) some points in one of his 87 leagues.

This is call that instant replay is suffering from overexposure. What began as a well-intentioned method of correcting blown calls that were the difference between winning and losing has exploded into nit-picking intrusion that causes unnecessary delays in the action to make minor fixes to rulings.

I am on the record as being pro-instant replay, and I still am. But the NFL has to find a way to limit the use cutting-edge technology from interrupting the flow of its games. The rampant use of replay and the development of high-definition video is quickly turning NFL games into an episode of CSI.

TD or No TD is a valid question, but do we really need TV to tell us if Player O’s toenail stepped out of bounds before Player X targeted him with the crown of his helmet? Or if the football broke some imaginary plane before the knee of the person holding it touched the ground? It’s like a Zapruder film marathon.

The footage that broke the camels back came during Sunday night’s showcase between the Kansas City Chiefs and Denver Broncos. After watching some of the most time-wasting replays all Sunday, the NFL saved its most ridiculous reviews for last, turning the last 5 minutes into an eternity and stretching the forgone conclusion of a game well past midnight.

The first one was fairly understandable: Trailing 27-10, Chiefs tight end Anthony Fasano made a leaping catch in the back of the end zone that was ruled out of bounds. But, upon further review and about 5 earth minutes, the head referee emerged from the hood to explain that Fasano’s right calf muscle touched in bounds before his butt cheek hit out of bounds. Body parts? Really?

After the call was overturned and the Broncos attempted to mercifully run out the clock, Wes Welker caught a pass and, while running out of bounds, stuck the football forward toward the first-down mark. Fourth down, said the ref. Challenge the spot, said the Broncos. So after surgerically breaking down the exact location of the ball at the exact moment he stepped out of bounds, the ball was respotted at the 31 1/4-yard line. That’s the 31 yard, 9-inch line for those without X-ray vision.

College football has an even bigger problem with its new targeting rule. If a referee thinks he says the call, he throws the flag, the offending player is ejected and the play is automatically reviewed. If the replay shows the player, in fact, did not illegal target, he gets to stay in the game but the penalty remains.  Try that in the real world: A judge tears up your ticket because he finds you not guilty but you still have to pay the fine.

The NFL and NCAA keep no stats on replay usage but the offseason rule change to review every scoring play, coupled with teams using assistants in the press box to green light or red light a review, is turning a nation of football fans into forensic scientists. And when the scene of the crime is prime time, casual viewers start flipping to the Puppy Bowl.

Comments

comments

Girls Lax: Sharks roll again; Panthers rally past Braves

Girls Lax: Sharks roll again; Panthers rally past BravesThe St. James girls lacrosse team continued its impressive opening [more]

Moglia rounds out staff with addition of Howe

Moglia rounds out staff with addition of HoweShawn Howe has been named defensive line coach, Coastal Carolina [more]

Athlete of Week: MB gets major impact from Smith

Athlete of Week: MB gets major impact from SmithIn a matter of months, Asia Smith has gone from [more]

Saints' season once again halted by Spartanburg Day

Saints' season once again halted by Spartanburg DayThe Christian Academy of Myrtle Beach boys basketball team's state [more]

Nash: Sharks, Braves tie; Chiefs, Seahawks prevail

Nash: Sharks, Braves tie; Chiefs, Seahawks prevailSix local high school girls soccer teams kicked off the [more]

DJ comes home for junior tourney, groundbreaking

DJ comes home for junior tourney, groundbreakingDustin Johnson returned to TPC Myrtle Beach to break ground [more]

MB native Sessions signs on for second stint in DC

MB native Sessions signs on for second stint in DCMyrtle Beach native Ramon Sessions isn't ready to call it [more]

Lady Panthers hit ground running in season opener

Lady Panthers hit ground running in season openerThe Carolina Forest girls lacrosse team showed flashes of mid-season [more]

Woodall homers twice as Chants shut out Cougars

Woodall homers twice as Chants shut out CougarsKevin Woodall Jr., hit two home runs and Kyle Skeels [more]

Boys Playoffs: Tigers fall; Saints advance to semis

Boys Playoffs: Tigers fall; Saints advance to semisConway High boys basketball team's bid for a state championship [more]

St. James opens lacrosse season with NMB sweep

St. James opens lacrosse season with NMB sweepAfter posting an undefeated regular season in 2017, the St. [more]

MB girls bounce AC Flora; face Wilson in Lower State

MB girls bounce AC Flora; face Wilson in Lower StateThe Myrtle Beach High girls basketball team has been battling [more]

Lady Panthers' playoff run cut short by Goose Creek

Lady Panthers' playoff run cut short by Goose CreekDespite a hard-fought match, the historic run of the Carolina [more]

Grand Strand Juniors claim Savannah Showdown titles

Grand Strand Juniors claim Savannah Showdown titlesThe Grand Strand Juniors Volleyball Club sent several teams to [more]

Chants run out of magic, suffer first loss to Indiana

Chants run out of magic, suffer first loss to IndianaIndiana, ranked 17th nationally, scored once in the seventh to [more]

CCU's Adams claims third Player of the Week award

CCU's Adams claims third Player of the Week awardJas Adams of the Coastal Carolina women’s basketball team was [more]

St. James' Knaffle, White receive major golf honors

St. James' Knaffle, White receive major golf honorsAfter leading the St. James High girls golf team to [more]

Chants post back-to-back, 10th-inning walk-off wins

Chants post back-to-back, 10th-inning walk-off winsFor the second straight game, Coastal Carolina (3-0) scored a [more]

Boys Playoffs: Tigers ride Wave into 5A LS semifinal

Boys Playoffs: Tigers ride Wave into 5A LS semifinalThe Conway High boys basketball team punched their ticket to [more]

NMB crowns 2 Lower State champs; CF, MB qualify 5

NMB crowns 2 Lower State champs; CF, MB qualify 5The North Myrtle Beach wrestling team crowned two Lower State [more]

Green comes off bench, leads Saints' playoff win

Green comes off bench, leads Saints' playoff winThe Christian Academy of Myrtle Beach boys basketball team needed [more]

CCU Hoops: Chants sweep USA in Senior Day thrillers

CCU Hoops: Chants sweep USA in Senior Day thrillersOn Senior Day, it was fittingly a senior-to-senior connection that [more]

Chants rally past Sooners on Wood's walk-off in 10th

Chants rally past Sooners on Wood's walk-off in 10thWith bases loaded and two outs in the bottom of [more]

5A Girls Playoffs: Panthers roll into Lower State semis

5A Girls Playoffs: Panthers roll into Lower State semisThe Carolina Forest girls basketball team are headed to the [more]

4A Girls Playoffs: Big win keeps Seahawks at home

4A Girls Playoffs: Big win keeps Seahawks at homeThe Myrtle Beach girls basketball team had to battle to [more]

Girls Lax: Sharks roll again; Panthers rally past Braves

Girls Lax: Sharks roll again; Panthers rally past BravesThe St. James girls lacrosse team continued its impressive opening [more]

Moglia rounds out staff with addition of Howe

Moglia rounds out staff with addition of HoweShawn Howe has been named defensive line coach, Coastal Carolina [more]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2017 Grand Strand Sports Report · RSS
Myrtle Beach Web Design
Kayaking in Myrtle Beach